Does Mr. Peanutbutter have BPD? (+7 Signs of issues)

This info-rich post will be discussing if Mr. Peanutbutter has BPD. We will also be listing out the various signs and symptoms of mental health issues that Mr. Peanutbutter shows in the series ‘Bojack Horseman’.

Does Mr. Peanutbutter have BPD?

No, Mr. Peanutbutter does not have BPD. In the comedy-drama series ‘Bojack Horseman’, Mr. Peanutbutter is never confirmed to have Borderline Personality Disorder. However, he seems to struggle from some other mental health disorder that is never quite mentioned in the series.

In the series, Mr. Peanutbutter is the friend of the titular character, Bojack Horseman, and is a male yellow Labrador-Retriever. He is a wealthy person who is constantly on-the-go in the series. He also goes through a number of failed relationships in the series.

Mr. Peanutbutter seems toxically positive in nature, but at many times he seems to drop his guard down and show a nihilistic side. A couple of theories regarding Mr. Peanutbutter’s mental health status as shown in ‘Bojack Horseman’ have been described as follows.

  • Histrionic Personality Disorder: One fan-theory regarding Mr. Peanutbutter’s mental health status is that he might have Histrionic Personality Disorder. He often seeks attention and aims to be in the spotlight at all times.
  • Narcissistic Personality Disorder: Another fan-theory regarding Mr. Peanutbutter is Narcissistic Personality Disorder. He is truly self-obsessed and constantly brings the topic of every conversation back to himself, annoying others in the process.
  • Dependent Personality Disorder: Some fans and critics also feel that Mr. Peanutbutter might have Dependent Personality Disorder. Throughout the series, he goes from relationship to relationship, and seems to be afraid of being alone.

Signs of Mr. Peanutbutter’s mental health issues

‘Bojack Horseman’ is one of the most progressive shows and covers a wide range of topics including mental health, and even social issues. One of the main characters in the series called Mr. Peanutbutter is often touted as a self-obsessed man-child.

Many fans and critics have felt that Mr. Peanutbutter truly fits the criteria of some mental health disorder, but no proper diagnosis has been confirmed by the creators of the character. Some signs of psychological issues that Mr. Peanutbutter seems to struggle from are described below.

Mr. Peanutbutter never really grows up

When compared to the other characters of the show, Mr. Peanutbutter never actually grows up. He is the definition of a man-child and stays this way until the end. This is not a sign of a mental health disorder, but shows emotional immaturity.

He shows toxic positivity

Toxic positivity is another characteristic trait of Mr. Peanutbutter. He is constantly upbeat and optimistic about everything and anything. Even when things are going downhill for Mr. Peanutbutter, he tends to look at the positive side even when it is very hard to do so.

This may seem like a very healthy thing, since almost every mental health expert out there routes for optimism. However, there is something called toxic positivity, which can lead to more distress, since it can cause the person to overlook the logical side of things.

He has poor intelligence

In the comedy-drama series ‘Bojack Horseman’, Mr. Peanutbutter is 52-years-old towards the end of the series. Despite his age, Bojack shows very poor intelligence and somehow cruises by on his good looks and luck.

Mr. Peanutbutter shows his poor intelligence in many conversations where he never seems to get the joke or understand the seriousness of the matter being discussed. The jokes that Mr. Peanutbutter cracks are often unintelligent and nobody gets them.

He acts quite spoilt

Mr. Peanutbutter is certainly wealthy and has luck on his side for most of the series. He is therefore very spoiled since he has never experienced any major challenges and actually has a very easy life.

This trait of Mr. Peanutbutter may not be the diagnostic criterion of any particular mental health disorder, but more so points to the entitlement that is present in personality disorders like Narcissistic Personality Disorder.

He seems very entitled

Apart from being spoiled, Mr. Peanutbutter also seems quite entitled. Since he has earned all of his money and wealth through very little work, he feels that he does not need to do any hard work if he needs to survive.

He also thinks that opportunities and wealth will just reach him automatically. For instance, he assumes that if he just walks around Los Angeles, a great work opportunity will reach him. He actually does go ahead and walk around, but nothing of that sort happens.

His entitlement basically stems from the fact that Mr. Peanutbutter got rich and famous very quickly with very less to no struggles as well. He barged into a live taping and got a part in Mr. Peanutbutter’s House with no previous acting experience at all.

This actually puts a strain on Mr. Peanutbutter’s and Bojack’s friendship as the later felt that the shoe was a knockoff of his own show. Since he achieved success quite easily and almost immediately, Mr. Peanutbutter expects the same treatment everywhere he goes.

Mr. Peanut butter can be quite nihilistic

While Mr. Peanutbutter may be the patron saint of toxic positivity in ‘Bojack Horseman’, he also shows a nihilistic and negative side to himself at times. For example, he says, “The key to being happy is to just distract yourself with unimportant nonsense until you eventually die.”

This statement from Mr. Peanutbutter actually comes as a surprise for many fans and critics of the show, since he is obviously positive and bouncy at other points of time. But, it also may denote that he puts on a façade of positivity to make up for the negativity inside.

He is terrible at relationships

Perhaps the best indication of Mr. Peanutbutter’s psychological issues is his poor performance in the relationship department. Throughout the series, Mr. Peanutbutter goes through multiple marriages and failed relationships.

Mr. Peanutbutter surely seems excited and ecstatic to be in a relationship and is never single for a long time. But, it is his approach in a relationship that brings up many red-flags in his personality.

For instance, when he dates Diane, he constantly comes up with grand and big gestures to prove his love to her. Diane frequently admits to Mr. Peanutbutter that she does not like any of this and does not encourage this behavior in the slightest bit.

But, Mr. Peanutbutter continues this behavior just to make sure that Diane won’t leave him or abandon him like his other partners. This again may be a sign of Dependent Personality Disorder in Mr. Peanutbutter.

In whatever relationship he may be in, Mr. Peanutbutter does not seem ready to listen to his partners or his wives. This problem in communication is the main reason why his relationships often break down in a bad way.

Mr. Peanutbutter also manages to go out of his way to date women who are significantly younger than him. Diane actually points out that while his partners certainly grow up after a while Mr. Peanutbutter stays the same mental and emotional age, which is a deal-breaker for his partners.

Mr. Peanutbutter also does not show any maturity in his breakups in relationships. When he cheats on Pickles with Diane, he is hesitant to break the news to her. He actually ends up proposing to Pickles which again turns out to be a tumultuous ride for both of them.


This info-rich post has discussed if Mr. Peanutbutter has BPD. We have also listed out the various signs and symptoms of mental health issues that Mr. Peanutbutter shows in the series ‘Bojack Horseman’.

If you like this post, please leave your comments and questions in the space below.